Are PCP Claims Real? Success Rates and Misconceptions

Guide 10 May 2025

headshot of Chris Roy, Product and Marketing Director of Reclaim247
Chris Roy
Man offering his hand to shake

As consumers, we’ve all seen the ads online promising compensation for mis-sold car finance. One of the most common claims we come across is for PCP claims (Personal Contract Purchase), but for many people, these adverts raise a lot of questions. "Are PCP claims legitimate?" and "Is this just another PPI-style money grab?" If you have ever in one time or the other find yourself asking whether it is worthwhile or not, you are not alone. This blog post is intended to answer those questions by taking a dive into actual facts, correcting common myths, and clarifying the increasing success of such claims. It entails a short assessment of future compensation opportunities along with instant endeavors at your disposal.

1. Are PCP Claims Legitimate?

First, let’s break down exactly what PCP claims are and why they have become so common. Consumers in the UK commonly use Personal Contract Purchase (PCP) to lease vehicles with the opportunity to purchase them after their leasing term. A lack of proper disclosure about essential terms caused many consumers to unknowingly accept mis-sold PCP agreements with hidden commissions and deceptive interest rates alongside high-pressure sales tactics. The most significant issue? Dealers were able to earn higher commissions by raising interest rates through discretionary commissions which consumers typically remained unaware of.

The transparency shortfall gives rise to a legitimate claim. Following extensive probes, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) released public advice in 2019 to confirm that mis-selling practices give rise to legitimate causes of action. The FCA investigation particularly aimed at some top lenders, such as Black Horse and Barclays Partner Finance, who were found to be engaged in these potentially deceptive practices.

If you think you have been mis-sold PCP agreement, then you might be one among thousands of car owners who have been duped into the contracts. The FCA's backing has helped establish that these claims are genuine and, in many cases, deserve compensation.

If you suspect that your agreement was mis-sold, you may be wondering how to claim mis-sold car finance. Begin your claim procedure by collecting all pertinent documents associated with your car finance contract. Your original finance contract, along with dealer or lender communications and documentation regarding hidden fees or misrepresented terms, form part of the necessary documents. Once you have collected these documents you can assess whether unfair practices affected you through inflated interest rates or undisclosed fees.

It might look overwhelming to submit a PCP claim, but knowing what is involved can make it a lot easier. The good news is that the process is now easier through the assistance of specialist claims companies and consumer protection bodies. In most cases, you would have to submit a formal complaint to your lender or dealer who issued your PCP contract. You can complain to the Financial Ombudsman Service if they have not resolved it to your satisfaction. A professional who knows the full details of PCP claims assists many consumers through legal complexities to maximise their chances of winning a claim. 

2. Common Misconceptions

Despite several false assumptions about PCP claims, experts have verified their validity. There are many misconceptions that experts are to clear up concerning PCP claims.

  • "This is just another PPI-style money grab."

In contrast to PPI claims, which were founded upon the mis-selling of payment protection insurance, PCP claims are based on explicit consumer protection legislation. PCP mis-selling stems from undisclosed important terms and deceptive interest rates that caused consumers to overpay for their car finance. This issue concerns addressing confirmed unfairness rather than opportunistic claims according to regulatory authorities such as the FCA.

  • "Only a few people are eligible."

Many people incorrectly believe that PCP claims are available to only a limited number of consumers. Tens of thousands of complaints have been filed and numerous individuals have received refunds or compensation as a result. The Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) research reveals many PCP claims achieve success especially when clear evidence of mis-selling exists.

  • "It’s too complicated to bother."

Car finance refund claims filing which once appeared complex now requires less effort than expected. Customers now have easy access to professional support through the increasing availability of claims support services. Claim specialists provide guided step-by-step services from assessing your finance agreement to filing a complaint with the lender.

3. Real-Life Outcomes and Case Studies

Real customer success stories can help you decide if pursuing PCP claims makes sense. Numerous reports with inflated interests have been repaid to customers following reveals of concealed commissions and conditions that were sold to them.

For example, a customer received refunds after discovering their car finance agreement included undisclosed commission fees that drove up their interest rate. The customer learned about the balloon payment near the end of their PCP contract and obtained a partial refund for excess charges by filing a successful claim. The anonymised cases show that PCP claims stem from real issues encountered by numerous consumers.

Has anyone had a successful PCP claim? The answer is yes and it is happening at a higher percentage. Many individuals who initially doubted whether they could receive compensation have been pleasantly surprised by the outcomes. A successful complaint, backed by evidence of misleading terms or sales practices will result in significant refunds. Consumers who were given misleading disclosures on balloon payments or concealed charges have received refunds by complaining to their lenders and through customer support services. These real-world examples show that PCP claims are not just a theoretical possibility—they are happening right now, and more people are being compensated every day.

These claims are sustained by the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) supplying independent decisions every time complaints arise. Several consumers received reimbursements through claim prosecutions which succeeded when they provided good evidence and supportive documents despite some cases resulting in loss.

4. Success Rates and Factors That Influence Payouts

You might be wondering: "What are the actual chances of success if I file a PCP car finance claim?" Success rates differ in complaints resolution yet evidence from the Financial Ombudsman Service shows that claims succeed between 30% to 50% based on specific conditions.

Documenting information properly increases the possibility of a successful claim. Documentation demonstrating misrepresented agreement terms significantly improves your likelihood of obtaining compensation. Artificial inflation of your interest rate through discretionary commissions strengthens your legal claim significantly when evidence supports this practice.

On the other hand, claims without supporting evidence—such as written communication, a copy of the agreement, or proof of misleading sales tactics—are less likely to succeed. This highlights the need for maintaining all documents concerning your car finance refund claim and collaborating with specialists who can ensure that any discrepancies are pinpointed.

5. The Bigger Picture: A Potential Redress Scheme?

Looking ahead, there is the possibility of a wider redress scheme for PCP claims. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has already put complaint deadlines on hold before expanding its investigation of PCP mis-selling. This has generated speculation that the FCA is likely to introduce a bulk redress scheme following the pattern of the PPI compensation scheme, which could mean automatic compensation to those consumers who are impacted.

While this potential plan would give consumers a huge chance to claim compensation, it's important to realise that PCP refund timelines might change as the FCA completes its guidance. If an extended redress scheme is implemented, then potentially the process may be made simpler for those entitled, but waiting too long could result in the loss of the ability to claim on an individual basis. Before any potential changes to refund deadlines take place, you should determine your eligibility because FCA may close the single claim window once its bulk redress program concludes.

These potential timelines should be monitored closely, as they will dictate the next steps for consumers who are unsure whether to submit a claim. Even if we don't know the complete story yet, this possible plan would mean that considerably more consumers could be due for compensation in the future. Nevertheless, it is important not to wait too long—once the FCA's review has taken place, it may become a different proposition to make individual claims, and consumers might miss out if they delay.

For those considering whether to file a claim, now is an opportune moment to check your eligibility for a PCP refund and to start gathering the necessary documents. It's still a good idea to start gathering all the necessary documents related to your PCP claim to ensure you're prepared when the timelines are finalised. Previous compensation programs demonstrate that early action tends to produce superior results.

Conclusion

Simply, PCP claims are justifiable and based on real consumer protection issues. Mis-selling of car finance contracts has already led to financial problems for thousands, and the possibility of redress schemes to occur in the future makes it even more important to take a look at your PCP contract. Whatever you are worried about - undisclosed commissions, balloon payments, or mis-sold car finance conditions - now is the time to take action.

Take action immediately to investigate if you suspect that your PCP deal was mis-sold. Start your investigation by reviewing your paperwork for signs of mis-selling and employ tools to recover funds from mis-sold car finance deals. Stay vigilant because the FCA investigation continues and mass compensation schemes might emerge. Your chance for a refund exists at this moment.

Related resources

Guide13 May 2025

Legal Grounds for Filing a PCP Finance Claim

Were you mis-sold a PCP finance agreement? Discover the key legal grounds for PCP finance claims in the UK, how to spot mis-sold PCP deals, and the steps to file a complaint. This guide covers your rights under the Consumer Credit Act, FCA regulations, and offers a step-by-step claims process with tips on gathering evidence and seeking support.

Guide13 May 2025

Mis-Sold PCP Car Finance Refunds: Average Payouts and Success Stories

Mis-sold PCP car finance agreements have led to thousands of UK consumers claiming compensation. This article explains how PCP refund amounts are determined, presents car finance refund success stories, and offers guidance on maximising your payout. Learn how to check your eligibility using a car finance refund checker and avoid common pitfalls in the claims process.

Reclaim247.co.uk is a trading style of Claimsline Group Ltd, registered in England and Wales, Company registration number 09071409. Registered Office: C/O Burton Varley Ltd, Suite 3, 2nd Floor, Didsbury House, 748 - 754 Wilmslow Road, Manchester, United Kingdom, M20 2DW. VAT registration number 199616255. Registered with the Information Commissioner's Office; registration number ZA059156. You can find our terms of use, privacy policy and our cookie policy here. Claimsline Group Ltd is a claims management company. Any solicitor we recommend you to is an independent professional from whom you will receive impartial and confidential advice. You are free to choose another solicitor. Claimsline Group Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority in respect of regulated claims management activities FRN Number is 831196.

1Where No Win, No Fee is offered - You pay nothing unless your claim is successful. A fee between 18 - 36% applies on successful claims (fee dependant on level of redress secured), and a cancellation fee may apply outside the 14 day cooling-off period.

2£5,492.10 is the figure disclosed to Bott & Co Solicitors by Black Horse. £4,478.46 is the figure disclosed to Bott & Co Solicitors by Motonovo. £2,449.65 is the figure disclosed to Bott & Co Solicitors by Close Brothers. £4,298 is the figure disclosed to Bott & Co Solicitors by Santander.

3All figures disclosed on the results page of our form are based on the average a client was overcharged during the FCA’s investigation.

4Free Online Checker refers only to the live soft-credit check completed online to identify your car finance agreements.