Lloyds, Close Brothers Among Banks Affected by Car Finance Claims Probe

Car Finance Claims Probe Could Cost UK Banks £16B including Lloyds and Close Brothers

multilevel parking space with cars

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) continues to investigate the car finance claims involving some of the biggest banks in the United Kingdom, with Lloyds Banking Group and Close Brothers getting significantly impacted. The scandal is expected to cost the car finance industry £16 billion driven by consumers who are alleged victims of mis-sold finance deals.

The watchdog seeks to shed light on loan handling by motor dealers, with particular attention to discretionary commission agreements (DCAs), which purportedly resulted in higher rates and fees. The investigation remains underway but has shown potential consequences for lending institutions, prompting them to reserve funds to cover car finance compensation costs.

Lloyds and Close Brothers affected by probe 

Investors, banks, and dealers have been preparing for compensation costs that could come from the investigation, which is predicted to fall between £6 billion and £16 billion. Major banks have been making moves to at least mitigate the impact of the review. 

Lloyds, regarded as one of the biggest motor lenders in the UK, is expected to carry the heaviest burden. RBC Capital Markets experts predicted the cost to be around £2 billion as the bank set a provisionary amount of £450 million as payment for potential redress. 

The bank, which owns Black Horse, is one of the biggest players in motor lending. It is believed to be the most exposed to DCAs, leading to a 14% drop in share price since January. This comes along with an anticipated drop of 110 in financial resilience basis points.

Another key player, Close Brothers, also announced a provision of £400 million in anticipation of payouts, given the £110 million in potential redress estimated by analysts. This calls into question the bank’s financial resilience, which is expected to erode by 270 basis points. 

The probable damages alerted investors as signalled by the almost 50% drop in stock price, pushing the bank to halt dividend distribution. 

Barclays and Santander funnelled funds toward compensation payouts, with an estimated redress of £250 million and £850 million, respectively.

Meanwhile, some institutions such as NatWest did not see much of an impact.

The probe, initiated in January this year, aims to determine whether financial institutions and motor brokers overcharged customers by adjusting interest rates and cost of car loans without sufficiently informing clients. 

EY, FCA join hands in car finance claims review

Consultancy firm Ernst & Young (EY) joined the FCA in assessing the scope of the scandal to the tune of £12 million in contracts. The two organizations will be looking into motor finance agreements dating back to 2007, indicating just how widespread the issue is. 

EY’s role is expected to provide additional measures in maintaining the integrity of the investigation as firms of its calibre are known for their expertise in regulatory reviews. It also serves to ensure thoroughness and fairness, especially in assessing compensation received by DCA victims. 

This partnership is an extension of the two organizations’ cooperation, signalling the scale of the work being done. The review, spanning over 14 years’ worth of agreements, came after the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) reported 17,000 car finance claims, many of which were done before the FCA banned DCAs in 2021.

According to the FCA, “If we find widespread misconduct, we will act to make sure people are compensated in an orderly, consistent and efficient way.”

Customers affected by mis-sold car finance overpaid an estimated of £300 million every year collectively, some paying around £1,100 more than the actual expense of holding a four-year car loan. The agency estimates around £160 million a year in savings. 

The Market faces further challenges as the probe progresses

The financial market has been taking cautious steps as the review continues, with investors keeping a close eye on lenders like Lloyds and Close Brothers. 

While some experts foresee substantial costs, the scale is not expected to reach that of the previous market scandal involving payment protection insurance (PPI). Nevertheless, smaller institutions may face considerable impacts.

The motor lending segment will be seeing substantive changes in the industry, especially in light of the Court of Appeal ruling siding with consumers in the consolidated landmark cases involving MotoNovo and Close Brothers. 

More will be revealed in the coming months as the FCA continues the probe and promises an update by May 2025. 

Related Blogs
Close Brothers to Sell Wealth Management Unit to Oaktree for £200 Million Amid Motor Finance Probe

Close Brothers has entered into an agreement to sell CBAM to Oaktree Capital for £200 million as part of its efforts to boost its financial position to brace for the impact of the FCA’s probe into the motor finance industry.

FCA Confirms Ban on Motor Finance Discretionary Commission; Effective January 2021

Financial watchdog FCA gives companies until January 2021 to comply with the ban on discretionary commission schemes used in the UK’s motor finance sector. Minor reforms were also made to the Consumer Credit sourcebook to ensure clarity over commission disclosure.

FCA Takes Action to Protect Motor Finance Consumers: £165 Million Savings Expected

UK’s financial watchdog, FCA, opens public consultation on its proposed ban on discretionary commission schemes used in the motor finance sector, and on minor reforms to the Consumer Credit sourcebook over commission disclosure standards.

Reclaim247.co.uk is a trading style of Claimsline Group Ltd, registered in England and Wales, Company registration number 09071409. Registered Office: C/O Burton Varley Ltd, Suite 3, 2nd Floor, Didsbury House, 748 - 754 Wilmslow Road, Manchester, United Kingdom, M20 2DW. VAT registration number 199616255. Registered with the Information Commissioner's Office; registration number ZA059156.

Where the service is offered at No win no Fee this means that a customer will typically pay 30% + VAT 36% including VAT of any amount recovered by a panel solicitor although this will be subject to your individual circumstances and the actual fee may be less than this, but it will never be more. A cancellation fee may be charged by a third party/panel solicitor if you cancel outside the cooling off period.

You do not need to use a claims management company to make a claim; you can do this yourself for free by contacting the car dealership or finance provider and if that is not successful you can complain to the Financial Ombudsman Service. We may receive a fee for introducing you to a third party/panel solicitor, this does not affect any compensation you may receive.

You can find our terms of use, privacy policy and our cookie policy here. Claimsline Group Ltd is a claims management company. Any solicitor we recommend you to is an independent professional from whom you will receive impartial and confidential advice. You are free to choose another solicitor.

**Roughly 90 per cent of new cars and 50% of used cars (https://www.autotrader.co.uk/content/news/mis-sold-car-finance-claims) You can find our terms of use, privacy policy and our cookie policy here.

***Average compensation of £1,600 source Bott & co (https://www.bottonline.co.uk/mis-sold-car-finance-claims) Representing thousands of clients, they have successfully won over 90% of mis-sold car finance claims that have gone to trial since January 2022, with the average pay out over £1,600 in compensation.

Claimsline Group Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN:831196). Claimsline Group is a claims management company and only undertakes marketing activities which comply with Solicitors Regulation Authority Code of Conduct 2011 (in particular, Chapter 8 - Publicity). Regulatory information.